Throughout the United States, asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material. However, most of the country does not contend with a climate like Arizona’s. In the Grand Canyon State, tile has long been a popular choice for homeowners looking for a durable roof.

However, times have changed, and asphalt shingle technology has improved considerably. In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of tile vs. shingle roofs so that you can make a great choice for your Arizona home.

Evaluating Tile vs. Shingle Roofs: Factors to Consider

We have broken down our comparison into key considerations to make it easier to choose the right material for your next roof replacement.

Durability

Tile roofs are famous for their durability. With good maintenance, you can expect a tile roof to last for 50 years or more.

In comparison, shingle roofs are not noted for their durability. Asphalt shingles typically last around 20 years. Some modern shingles come with a 25-year warranty, but you should expect to replace them every 2 decades.

Verdict: Tile roofs are the clear winners, with more than double the average lifespan of shingle roofs.

Fire and UV-resistance

Tile roofs are naturally fire-resistant. They also withstand UV rays well. However, you will need to monitor the underlayment and roof structure, which are not fireproof and can also degrade over time.

When choosing asphalt shingles, look for “Class A” in the description. Class A shingles are considered fire-resistant, but other Class B and C do not offer the same protection. Asphalt shingles are made using an oil byproduct, and UV rays can dry this out over time. However, modern shingles use granules that are better able to resist UV rays, extending the lifespan of the roof.

Verdict: Despite advancements in shingle technology, tile roofs still have the edge.

Maintenance

Tile roofs are not susceptible to many issues that require regular maintenance. For example, mold does not grow on them, and insects are unable to attack them. Tiles cannot rot, and as long as you do not walk on them, they are strong and unlikely to crack. Due to these factors, tile shingles often come with long manufacturer’s warranties.

On the other hand, asphalt shingles are more high-maintenance. They are prone to mold and algae growth, which has to be removed regularly. Eventually, they break down, and the granules can accumulate in roof valleys and gutters. The shingles also crack and curl, needing replacement after years of sun exposure.

Verdict: Their low-maintenance credentials make tile roofs the winner in this category.

Weight

Tile roofs are much heavier than asphalt roofs, often requiring up to 4 times more reinforcement than asphalt roofs. You will need to have your home inspected to check whether it can bear the weight of a tile roof.

Verdict: The weight of a tile roof could be a dealbreaker for people whose homes are not strong enough to support one.

Cost

Tile roofs may last longer than asphalt, but they cost much more. NerdWallet estimates that the price range for clay tile roofs in 2025 is $12–$25 per square foot. The range for asphalt shingles is $3.40–$8.75.

Of course, it is important to talk to a local roofing contractor and source quotes for both materials. Also, the lower maintenance costs and longer lifespan of tile roofs must be considered.

Verdict: Asphalt roofs generally win on cost, but the jury is out on value.

Aesthetics

Of course, home aesthetics are a matter of personal taste. That being said, if you want to give your home a classic Southwest look, tile is a great starting point.

While shingles do not have the texture and traditional styling of tile, they have improved a lot in recent years and offer a wide variety of looks for homeowners to choose from.

Verdict: Both tiles and shingles can give your home a stylish look, but many homeowners prefer the quintessential Southwest look of a tile roof.

Get the Perfect Roof From Overson Roofing

Tile and shingle roofs both have excellent qualities and provide long-term protection for your Arizona home. The choice often comes down to budget and style considerations.

At Overson Roofing, we pride ourselves on installing outstanding roofs, whether you choose tile, shingle, or another roofing material. With over 40 years of experience, we understand the local climate and home styles.

When we visit to carry out a free roof estimate, we will be happy to advise you on the cost and logistics of both options. Call us at 480-354-2564 or contact us online to schedule your free roof estimate today.